Opinion/Comment, Politics

“Current sports rorts affair worse than Ros Kelly’s”

As leader of the Liberal Party and opposition, I drove the sports rorts scandal against Ros Kelly, the then sports minister in the Keating government, back in 1994. It resulted in her ultimate resignation.

The sports rorts scandal involving the current Sport Minister, Bridget McKenzie, is worse.

By John Hewson

I was staggered that it took Prime Minister Scott Morrison almost two weeks to begin to deal with McKenzie. This is an open-and-shut case of the abuse of her position for political gain.

Labor's Ros Kelly resigned in 1994 after the $30 million "sports rorts" affair.
Labor’s Ros Kelly resigned in 1994 after the $30 million “sports rorts” affair.Credit:Mike Bowers

I was staggered again on Wednesday by the arrogant way Morrison dispensed with questioning of his handling of the scandal at the National Press Club.

In Ros Kelly’s case, at least, there was no doubt that she had the power to make the allocations of the sporting grants that she made. The focus was on Kelly’s poor administration and blatant politics. She made the decisions about the grants on a whiteboard, then erased them.Advertisement

Related Article

Prime Minister Scott Morrison says his office wasn't involved in running a controversial $100 million sports grants scheme.
Related article: Morrison distances his office from ‘sports rorts’, defends scheme

There is serious doubt that McKenzie had such power. Sport Australia had been empowered by the Parliament to run the program, independent of government. It is now clear, from documents obtained by the ABC, that McKenzie ignored the pre-election warnings of Sport Australia that her interference was compromising its independence.

In ducking the Press Club questioning, Morrison argued at length, as a distraction, that there are many “worthy” projects. He emphasised that the Auditor-General had not referred to any “ineligible projects”, and that as ministers he and his colleagues were “more in touch” with communities and what they needed than, by implication, bureaucrats.

Morrison didn’t acknowledge any political bias in the allocation of the grants; he wouldn’t concede they were made for political expediency rather than merit.

There is no doubt that McKenzie had a significant conflict of interest in making a grant to a clay-shooting club of which she was a member, especially if, as it seems, this conflict was never materially declared by her at relevant points in the grants process.

The key initial finding by the Auditor-General is that some 73 per cent of grants given had not been recommended by Sport Australia, but were allocated by her and her office to marginal seats that the government wanted to win or hold at the election.

Nationals Senator Bridget McKenzie's sports grants troubles are eerily similar to those of Keating-era sports minister Ros Kelly.
Nationals Senator Bridget McKenzie’s sports grants troubles are eerily similar to those of Keating-era sports minister Ros Kelly. Photo:Alex Ellinghausen

It is now reported that the Prime Minister’s office was involved in the allocation of these grants, along with the government members and senators. Morrison himself announced a $200,000 grant in his own electorate. Again, Morrison did not directly address questions at the Press Club, except to suggest he passed on information that he had relevant to the grants, “as all PMs do”.

Tony Harris, the former auditor-general in NSW, said recently that if this issue had come across his desk he would have passed it immediately to the Independent Commission Against Corruption. Clearly McKenzie’s processes corrupted the established government process in an attempt to gain political advantage.

How is it that this didn’t immediately ring alarm bells for Morrison? Apart from the usual reluctance of PMs to fire a minister, was he concerned about declaring and defending his role and that of his office and colleagues?

Related Article

Senator Bridget McKenzie at the Wangaratta Clay Target Club
Senator McKenzie
Related article: The gun club was suffering lead poisoning… until Bridget arrived

Morrison has compounded his problems by initiating two faux inquiries, rather than move immediately to terminate McKenzie. Can Attorney-General Christian Porter really be objective when sports organisations in his seat received more than  $1 million in grants?

Phil Gaetjens, now the head of the Prime Minister’s Department, having previously been Morrison’s chief of staff, is heading the inquiry. This, in itself, raises obvious questions about conflict of interest.

But why did Morrison try to narrow the focus to a possible breach of the ministerial code of conduct (that is, the possible conflict of interest in allocating about $36,000 to McKenzie’s clay-shooting club) when she had misallocated almost three-quarters of the $100 million grant money?

In marshalling evidence against Ros Kelly, I had our members report to me on the grants made to organisations in their seats, the stated purpose and the realities. Not surprisingly, some grants were found to be inexplicable – the likes of a grant for lights on a sporting field that didn’t exist. It appears there may have been similar abuses in McKenzie’s allocations – funding for women’s toilets at a venue where the women’s team had been disbanded.

Related Article

Nationals deputy leader Bridget McKenzie officially approved a grant for a shooting club just four days after becoming a member.
Related article: McKenzie joined a gun club four days before approving grant funding

The government can expect a tirade of discontent from those organisations whose projects had been highly rated by Sport Australia, but ignored by McKenzie.

Sure, it is difficult for Morrison as McKenzie is from the National Party, its deputy leader no less, and technically the Nats’ leader, Michael McCormack, would have to fire her. McCormack also clearly doesn’t want to reopen leadership tensions in his party, with Barnaby Joyce likely to want to run amok, and with the conspicuous ambitions of David Littleproud and Matt Canavan.

However, Morrison has made a lot of his setting of, and adherence to, the highest standards of ministerial responsibility and accountability. He simply must enforce these, by firing McKenzie, especially when his leadership has been under a cloud over his mishandling of the bushfires.

He should also undertake to establish a federal ICAC – or a corruption watchdog with as much bite – to establish a framework within which these issues can be dealt with fairly and expeditiously.


John Hewson is a professor at the Crawford School of Public Policy, ANU, and a former Liberal opposition leader.

First published at The Sydney Morning Herald Thursday 30 January 2020. See; https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/i-hounded-ros-kelly-until-she-resigned-but-bridget-mckenzie-s-sports-rorts-are-worse-20200129-p53vsa.html

6 Comments

  1. I remember having a grudging respect for John Hewson, despite our political differences, and he did the right thing in bringing down Ros Kelly. Cheating is cheating, no matter what flavour politics you favour.

    He sums up the whole, foul, McKenzie-Morrison mess succinctly. McKenzie must go, and Morrison can carry her bags.

  2. Looks like the National Party memo has been sent out to local members instructing them to convince their electorates that the ‘sportsrorts’ is a beatup, notwithstanding the scathing Auditor General’s report and condemnation by just about everyone else. Even our very own member, who conducted an unprecedented dirty tricks campaign against Rob Oakeshot during the last election got prominent exposure on page 3 of today’s Advocate calling such a suggestion as “fanciful”. The $800,000 in grants spent locally just reflects how concerned the LNP were at the time that Oakeshot posed a real threat after so much local disenchantment with the former member for Cowper.

  3. Not as smart

    Spot on

  4. The good ole National Party slogan from the 1920s till the 1970s was ‘countrymindedness”.It carried them for years .Its new slogan now should be “bloodymindedness” They are the economic /social gatekeepers for many parts of regional Australia,although they have less than 5% of the primary vote.On many issues they have hijacked debate in rural Australia with scaremongering eg climate change, fires,land clearing even electric cars.The scare campaign saying farmers would lose their utes because of electric cars was solid bs gold!!Yet their support for farmers/rural is questionable.They have failed with drought relief and bureaucracy for these grants (but a gun club can get grants or even womens toilets for a football club with no women members).A drought minister Barnaby Joyce who submits a drought report to the PM by text!!It is no surprise that our local member regards the grants scandal as “fanciful”

  5. Little Charlie

    I recall a tale from the 50’s wherein the leader of the Country Party,as it was known then, John “Black Jack” McEwen was giving a speech at an election rally in the bush before the days of mass media. His rousing call to the attending Country Party faithful was ended with “…and don’t forget I will always be a Country member.” A voice from up the back called out “Yeah we remember!” It appears respect for the Nats has changed little.

  6. The snail paced government has moved.Bridget has finally resigned reluctantly .Even still no admission of the issue , only that she joined the gun club that received funding .The National party foghorn clown Barnaby will contest leadership tomorrow. How good is that ?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*